
Duel of Hearts
When lovely young Miss Laura Milbanke was asked for her hand in marriage in romantic Venice, the irresistibly handsome Sir Nicholas Grenville was at death's door. He had fought a disastrous duel to defend Laura's honor, and now he would defend her from poverty by leaving her his estate when he died.
But Sir Nicholas did not die. He lived to bring Laura home to King's Cliff manor. Waiting for him was the fabulously beautiful Augustine Townsend, whom Nicholas had long adored and who would be his - if only Laura did not stand in the way.
Should Laura try to fight this ravishing rival? Or should she give her husband his freedom by giving herself to the temptingly attractive Daniel Tregarron, who offered her all the love Sir Nicholas denied her? Never did a young bride find herself in a greater dilemma - as a marriage that broke all the rules threatened to break her heart...
Original Publisher: Signet
Original Year of Publication: 1983
Page Count: 250
The
July 2025 #TBRChallenge is “Back in My Day...” and I decided to have a bit of fun with this prompt. Curious as to how many vintage romance novels I own that fall into my birth year, I ran a search on LibraryThing (seriously, LT is an
amazing catalog, OMG) and came up with 4 possibilities. This book sounded the most promising, so here it is. This is what was being published the same year I came into existence!
As the book opens, we find Miss Laura Milbanke in the principal bedchamber of the luxurious Hotel Cantorini on the Grand Canal in Venice. Laura awakens in this most extravagant and exclusive suite and we learn her backstory: orphaned as a child, she was sent to live with an aunt who treated her like an unwanted poor relation. She was treated as being somewhere between the gently bred family of her aunt and the servants belowstairs. She was given an education, and basically lived in her uncle's library, but when her aunt died, her cousins turned her out of the house with only the small inheritance she had been bequeathed in her relative's will. She will have to take a job in service, likely as a companion to an odious old spinster, but decides that before she heads for a life of drudgery, she will indulge in a burning dream: to visit this grand hotel in this grand city. She basically blows her money on a month-long stay, living a life amongst the Quality and doing her best to dodge the Austrian army officers who have taken up residence.
She is so immersed in her delight that she steps out onto her balcony in her nightgown to watch the sun rise. She's brought back to herself when she spots a lone gondola in the Canal, with an impossibly handsome passenger. She ducks back into her suite and figures she'll never run into him because she's taking a self-guided tour of the city and it does not involve impossibly handsome men.
This man is Sir Nicholas Grenville, the only other English person staying at her hotel, so she is seated with him for meals. He is less than welcoming, buried in his ledgers, and it basically makes for awkward company. Then an oily creep named Baron Frederick von Marienfeld takes an interest in her and she basically sticks close to Sir Nicholas because even his unpleasant company is better than the Baron's. Nicholas warns Laura against the Baron (as if she needed to be warned) and says that he is the finest duelist on the Continent, having successfully dispatched 11 previous rivals.
The Baron manages to corner Laura one day into a compromising position, and Sir Nicholas sweeps to her rescue, accepting the Baron's hastily offered duel for her honor. Laura is horrified; the man barely knows her and has made it more than clear that he can't stand her, so why in the world would he fight a duel because of her??
Nicholas finally relents, apologies for his atrocious behavior, and tells Laura his own backstory. He has just inherited King's Cliff Manor in Somerset, and the vast property is beyond broke. His father spent far more than the incomed earned off the property, and threw lavish events, including a huge annual hunt that bankrupted the place. He died and left Nicholas to face the music, and Nicholas knows that the only way to save the property is to tighten the belt of the finances, including doing major things like disbanding the hunt, selling extra properly, and draining the marshland. He knows that the estate will be in an uproar about all of the changes, including his father's former ward, the beautiful Augustine Townsend. Nicholas fancies himself in love with Augustine, but openly wonders - basically
believes - that she cares more about the house than him, as it was not that long ago that the Grenvilles bought the estate from the Townsends. Augustine and her mother have lived at King's Cliff their entire lives, and it was always assumed Augustine would marry the heir to the estate, thus bringing it back to her family.
Nicholas escaped from England for much the same reason that Laura did: to get away from the drudgery of his life and indulge himself one last time. As they find they have more in common than previously believed, they decide to spend the day before the duel together, exploring the beautiful city.
The duel comes and goes. Nicholas was gravely wounded, but not killed, and the Baron was chased out of the country due to his actions (shooting an unarmed man). Nicholas is brought back to the hotel, and Laura is shocked to learn that he has asked that she basically be his patient advocate with the local doctor. The doctor wants to amputate his arm; Nicholas adamantly refuses to have such a thing done, and it's up to Laura to abide by his wishes. She does so, and the doctor basically tells her that she's signed his death warrant.
But Nicholas lives through the night, and continues to hang on with the bullet still lodged in his arm. After a couple of days, he requests that Laura accept his hand in marriage, thus freeing her from having to take up paying work, even if he dies. They are married in his sick room, and soon make the voyage home, to King's Cliff, taking the sea route instead of overland due to his wound.
The sea journey is horrible and prolonged; by the time they make it to England, Nicholas is sick with ague. He insists on going home and calling in his personal physician; the group is surprised when they are stopped at the gate of King's Cliff because the guard can't believe he's still alive. Apparently word had been sent that he had died in Venice, and the house is appropriately dressed in deepest mourning. The servants are astounded that he has returned, albeit barely alive, and tell Laura they are glad she is there because none of them wanted to serve Augustine as Lady Grenville.
As it turns out, Augustine and her mother are away, having gone off to Grenville cousin the Earl of Langford to attend a big party. An odd thing to do when they are supposed to be in mourning, and indeed, when Laura sees them later as they return to the house, they appear to be drunk in celebration. The news that Nicholas lives is an ugly surprise, indeed!
If, at this point, you have surmised (as I did) that the Earl plotted to have Nicholas killed by the baron in Venice so that he might usurp King's Cliff *and* Augustine, congratulations, you have discovered the big denouement of the third act.
Daniel Tregarron, Nicholas's personal physician and best friend, meets Laura as she arrives with her gravely ill husband. He immediately tends to him, wanting to bring down the fever. He tells Laura that he is aware of a new type of surgery that can be done to remove the bullet from the body without amputation; it is done with sweet vitriol, aka ether as an anesthetic. Daniel tells Laura that it is safe because he has experimented with the sweet vitriol himself, and felt no pain. He wants permission to do the surgery, which Laura as Nicholas's wife can give. She thinks it over very carefully, and assents. They will have to wait until he has recovered from the infection (believed to be malaria) and can be weaned from the laudanum, which is contraindicated to the anesthetic.
Meanwhile, Augustine makes her presence well known. She immediately throws herself by Nicholas's sickbed, weeping with supposed joy at his return and anxiety that he will not live. She pushes Laura completely out, and when not in Nicholas's bedroom, she is a cruel bitch to her. Augustine lords it over Laura that Nicholas intended to marry
her upon his return from Venice, and surely when he recovers his senses he will annul his unconsummated marriage, set Laura aside, and marry her. Augustine is proud, vain, and conceited, and she does her best to run roughshod over Laura. She is sure that nothing will change; Nicholas will relent and let her have her way, including her continued lavish lifestyle.
Laura assumes that Augustine is right; after all, Nicholas told her as much in Venice, but she's not going to be set aside quite as easily as that. Daniel Tregarron and the estate agent, Charles Dodswell, want to honor Nicholas's plans for saving the estate, and that will only happen if Nicholas gives Laura power of attorney to act in his stead while he is still ill. There is an urgency to this, because a notorious London loanshark is calling in a debt that cannot otherwise be paid. Nicholas is well enough after being weaned from the laudanum to understand and agree with their plan, so he signs over POA the night before the planned surgery.
This, of course, outrages the Earl of Langford and the Townsends; legally, Laura is the head of the family and they can't cross her, no matter how much they want to. Temporarily thwarted, Augustine decides to put her acid tongue to good use, and starts spreading rumors that Laura is having a passionate affair with Daniel. The two spend a lot of time together, because Daniel is the only person in the house who is civil to her, but once tongues start wagging, things take a turn for the worse.
Daniel successfully operates and removes the bullet from Nicholas's arm. He leaves the house soon after, leaving Laura at the mercy of the nasty Townsend women. Rumors are running wild, and some of the servants have turned against Laura for her perceived betrayal of their master. No one dares tell her what's being said, not even her maid, so she's left to wonder why she's suddenly getting the cold shoulder.
Someone does eventually tell Daniel, and he decides that it's to his advantage to let the rumors swirl. He's fallen in love with Laura and would do anything to break up her marriage to his best friend, up to and including lying about their relationship to said friend. Nicholas inevitably hears the rumors and is deeply hurt, once again turning cold and dour towards Laura.
The misunderstanding is woven fairly deftly into the story, but it goes on way longer than it should have. Laura doesn't know that she's been linked to the doctor, so of course she seeks out his company as a friend; Daniel soon turns on her and tells her that he will pursue her because he can give her the love and affection Nicholas obviously won't; Nicholas forbids her from seeing him because he's angry and jealous, but refuses to tell Laura why. More than once I just wanted to shake him (and her!) and tell them to use their words already! The two are painfully in love, but both believe the other wants out in order to marry someone else.
Things get really ugly at the end, as Nicholas discovers the plot against him, and Augustine continues to spread lies about Laura even on her way out the door. The big conversation that straightens out everyone's feelings literally happens on the next-to-last page. It is a good one, very emotional and tugging at the heartstrings, but MAN does it happen too late to really matter.
I liked Nicholas until he decided to be a Proud Man instead of an understanding one; Daniel's turn to the dark side was unexpected, and mostly done quite nicely until he forgot how to accept "no" as a complete answer. Laura was a bit wishy-washy, but I found it to be mostly understandable; she loves her husband and doesn't want to leave, but doesn't want to commit herself to a life of 1000% misery, either. The villains are appropriately villainous and get their appropriate comeuppance, but I would've liked to enjoyed wallowing in it for a bit longer. They are all
so cruel to Laura, right up until the end. She needed more time to feel triumphant, IMO.
All in all, not the best I've read by this author, unfortunately, but it is a strong plot with interesting characters, so worth a read if you are a trad Regency purist.
⭐⭐1/2